‘Ethics’ of Trap dustshootJuly 16, 2010
There were plays that revolved around this card, which i was joking about it being “the ethics of trap dustshoot”.
Although it’s a well-known card, but still let’s have a look at the card again.
Activate only when your opponent has 4 or more cards in their hand. Look at your opponent’s hand, select 1 Monster Card in it, and return that card to its owner’s Deck.相手の手札が４枚以上の場合に発動する事ができる。相手の手札を確認してモンスターカード１枚を選択し、 そのカードを持ち主のデッキに戻す。
This is not a ruling article, so i will just skip the details. When you look at your opponent’s hand through Trap dustshoot, you select a monster card and return it to its owner’s deck. Simple.
It is very common that after a player selects a card in his opponent’s hand to return to its owner’s deck, he requests to have a look at his opponent’s hand again. Usually, he gets to view it again out of courtesy of his opponent. However, his opponent has the right to reject that, since after a card is selected and return to its owner’s deck, the effect is over.
Bahamut was saying he read from somewhere that this happened in a tournament and a judge allowed the player to view his opponent’s hand again. To prevent such situation, it is best to memorise the cards in opponent’s hand before you identify which card do you want to select, although you may have already made up your mind. Or you may write it on a piece of paper.
Another situation is when opponent has only one monster in his hand. He, being too helpful, chooses it for you and starts to shuffle it into his deck while he reveals his hand on the table. You don’t get to see what is that card that he shuffles back. He tells you what that card is but there is no way you can confirm it since it is in deck. He may even lie about it.
This is not exactly an ‘ethics’ issue but just a term i gave it just now.
Nevertheless, avoid such situations as much as possible.
P.S. Just in case not all of you can tell that recording your opponent’s hand on a piece of paper is just a joke, it’s a joke.